Africa to Torch Seized Ivory in Show of Disgust At the Killing of Elephants

by May 13, 2011Elephants

Nairobi — In another dramatic show of Africa’s hatred against the killing of the African elephant, the continent’s wildlife-range states plan to torch tons of stockpiles of ivory in the depth of Kenya’s Tsavo National Park next July, according to highly-placed sources within the wildlife sector.

The burn, what conservationists describe as a “leap of faith in the conservation of the elephant”, will cap a series of activities to include a meeting of ministers from countries teeming with wildlife, that include Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania, Zambia, Ethiopia, Sierra Leone, Dr Congo, Zambia and Lesotho.

The ministers will then launch the first African Elephant Law Enforcement Day as well as the African Wildlife Enforcement Monitoring System in Nairobi.

It is still not clear the quantity of tusks to be reduced to ashes. But the source said “over 10 tons”, to include the 6.5 ton (531 elephant tusks) consignment seized in Singapore in June 2002 and later traced to Zambia, will be set ablaze.

This contraband is safeguarded at the Kenya Wildlife Service, which headquarters the Lusaka Agreement Taskforce (LATF) – a meeting of nine African countries to stop illegal trade in animals and plants.

It is instructional to note that the 6.5-ton cache of ivory was once at the centre of a diplomatic incident between Kenya and Zambia when a section of the Lusaka Parliament demanded it back.

According to a source at the LATF, the agency expected to coordinate the burning, the event will demonstrate yet again Africa’s disgust at the killing of its wildlife, a resource that brings in eight of the 10 shillings earned by the tourism industry.

“It is going to be another historical event. And it will send a clear message to the whole world that Africa is ready to cooperate to conserve its heritage and economic resource,” he said.

Contacted, Paul Udoto, the Kenya Wildlife Service (KWS) spokesperson, said, thus: “I know there’s going to be an important activity soon, probably in July”. But he couldn’t confirm the plan to torch the ivory.

Experts regard the ivory burn as another first by Kenya, a country that spearheaded the ban on international trade in elephant and rhino horns in 1989. On July 18, 1989, former President Moi flamed 12 tons of ivory, in a historic gesture that transfixed the world to the plight of the African elephant.

The site where $1 million (Sh83 million) worth of ivory went up in smoke is symbolically preserved in the heart of Nairobi National Park.

Said Moi: “To stop the poacher, the trader must be also be stopped and to stop the trader, the final buyer must be convinced not to buy ivory … I appeal to people all over the world to stop buying ivory.”

The same year, 1989, palaentolgist Richard Leakey rallied the world round the elephant as well as rhino threatened by poachers.

Kenya’s elephant population had plunged from 130,000 to 26,000 in just 10 years prior to the ban, at the hand of poachers. Since then, Kenya has made huge seizures of contraband ivory. Today it has 65 tons of ivory stockpiles.

That the country is sternly opposed to resumption of trade in ivory, some or most of this pile will be destructed to send a message to the world that any dealings in elephant tusks would be detrimental to Africa’s wildlife.

However, other sources say the Cabinet will have to decide on what to do with Kenya’s ivory pile-up ahead of the July date.

“I am told that the Cabinet will have to decide by July. But the rest, ivory sourced outside Kenya, will be burned. That I am sure about.”

Exactly 22 years separate the planned event in Tsavo and the historical torching by President Moi. Yet those in the conservation circles predict another round of controversy drawing the pro-elephant lobby against an emerging voice by a host of African countries, Tanzania included, pressuring the international community to lift the ban on trans-boundary trade in ivory.

Tanzania is a key source. Not just for the ivory trafficked through Kenya but also in terms of seizures worldwide. Two years ago, the country accounted for half of the world’s 24-tonne seizure of ivory. Most of it came from the 54,600 square kilometres Selous Game Reserve and is shipped through Dar es Salaam and Mombasa ports.

Two years ago, Tanzanian authorities appealed to the Convention of International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES), the global agency that slammed the ban on trade in ivory and rhino horns, to temporarily lift the moratorium to enable it dispose 89.8 tons of ivory stockpile.

Authorities in the country had expected to raise funds from the sale to help it manage some of its wildlife conservation programmes.

Experts in wildlife matters are convinced Tanzania is in a technical bind – and are hardly surprised the neighbouring country may not be comfortable with the planned destruction of ivory at Tsavo next July.

Tanzania’s recurrent budget for the ministry of Natural Resources and Tourism for 2010/11 was a paltry TSh65.5 billion (Sh3.8 billion) which can be recouped through the sale of just 20 tons of ivory. (KWS’s budget is Sh7 billion)

“I am waiting to see how it plays out. Will Tanzania be part of the ivory burning event?” asks a scientist who formerly worked at the African Wildlife Foundation. “There are fundamental differences in conservation approaches between the two countries, Kenya and Tanzania.”

It is instructional to note that the plan to torch ivory comes barely a week after Kenya made one of its largest recoveries yet, a 1.3-ton ivory cache suspected to originate in DR Congo.

“Preliminary results show that the bulk of tusks were of forest elephants,” said Mr Udoto. “It is not conclusive but (the ivory) is likely to have come from Congo.” (Kenya’s elephant is the savannah type)

“We have to do an elaborate DNA test to be sure about the exact origin of the tusks.”

Kenya is emerging as the world’s largest transit point for illicit ivory. The amount of contraband ivory recovered here has jumped up nine-fold in the past five years, from 620 kilos in 2005 to 5.7 tons last year, according to recent tally by LATF. Over three tons of elephant tusks have been recovered this year alone.

“We are losing species of high value,” says Hadley Becha, a former executive director of East African Wildlife Society (EAWLS), who now heads the non-governmental organization, Community Action for Nature Conservation (CANCO). “We have to cooperate at the regional level to stem the flow of illicit ivory.”

Much of contraband ivory is sourced outside the country, and wildlife experts pick Tanzania and DR Congo as key supplies. South Africa, Zambia, Zimbabwe also account for the ivory that passes through Kenya to Asia.

Indeed, last week’s seizure points to two conveyor belts that pour into Kenya: One forks out from central Africa, specifically, the DR Congo, and the other emerges in southern Africa — as far down as South Africa.

Various reasons can explain the sheer amount recovered in Kenya: The country has an enabling environment for criminals to operate; authorities are very hawk-eyed they bust the syndicates easily.

Kenya’s advanced telecommunication industry enables organised criminals to easily hawk their merchandise using high technology methods.